Oct 12 2005

Pain and Humiliation

Published by Donna at 11:35 pm under mind, rant

I will mark this day on my calendar. Today I experienced perhaps one of the most humiliating moments of my life — and I did so before an audience of my peers.

However, in every experience, whether good or bad, there are lessons to be learned. I learned more than my share tonight.

Before I dive headlong into my rant, let me set the stage for you.

I struggled through this course, mainly because of our team’s inability to, well, be a “team.” Two of the four teammates were not responsive at all and barely put in a good 10 minutes worth of effort into our group assignments and final project. To make matters worse, the two had not prepared anything for the presentation and had not given me any feedback on the PowerPoint slides that I sent to everyone well in advance.

The first thing one of them asked me was whether I had print-outs of the slides. Hel-LO. I am not your mother. You had a soft copy of the file, why didn’t you print them out yourself? I bit my tongue. Instead, I said, “I only have my copy,” holding up my neatly stapled set. I slid it over to him, already feeling more than a tinge of irritation.

He and the other guy scrutinized it as if it was the first time they were seeing it. I believe it probably was.

Getting nervous now, I asked the guy, “So… you are doing the conclusion, right?”

He looked at the slides and said, “there’s no slide for it.”

Appalled, I said, “I didn’t get anything from you to add to it.” I had given them more than enough time and opportunities to add or make changes to the PowerPoint. In fact, when I had solicited for content, the two of them did not respond at all — so I took it upon myself to populate their portions with a few bullets taken from our paper.

Since we were on break and half of the class was still at the vending machines buying their sodas, probably looking more annoyed than I wished to convey, I offered, “I can add a slide with a few bullets right now, if you want.”

“Yeah, otherwise, I’m gonna have to read right from the paper. Do you have the paper?” He had the tone of someone who had expected something. Expected me to think for him. Expected me to hold his hand and do everything for him. As if his mere presence was effort enough to earn him full credit on this project that he had barely contributed to.

Good heavens. I passed him a printed copy of our paper.

“Okay, what do you want to add?” I asked as I loaded the PowerPoint file on the presentation computer.

“Whatever.”

I looked at him and waited for him to give me his bullet points. After all, he was the one presenting the content. I would hope that he would’ve had at least a vague idea of what he was going to say.

Nada.

“Whatever you put up there is fine. I’m just gonna wing it.”

Wing it? You idiot, I’m gonna wing your neck pretty soon.

By this time, I was livid. I pulled three bullet points, basically B.S., out of my butt thin air. He was still seated, not making any effort to come over to the computer to help me come up with ideas. I mean, geez, could you at least pretend to care?

“Do you want to look at this??” I asked.

He slowly stood and looked at what I had typed for all of five seconds and sat back down.

By now, I was upset. It was the culmination of five weeks of frustration. While the exchange was not overtly confrontational or hostile, his display of apathy and disregard for the clear disparity of effort was a total slap in the face. A few moments later, the class was back and we were on.

I couldn’t focus. My mind drew a complete blank. I tried to speak, but I could barely formulate a coherent sentence. I was supposed to be doing the introduction, but all I was doing was fumbling for the right word and saying a lot of “umm’s” and “uhh’s.” I believe I experienced a complete meltdown right there in front of the entire class. I ended up reading the bullet points on the slides and quickly handing it off to the next presenter: the other “over-achiever” in the group, the savior of our presentation.

I had to present my portion again about midway through. It started out okay, but quickly degenerated into an incomprehensible mess. The only thing that I didn’t do was physically fall on my face. Perhaps if I wasn’t riveted to my spot, I might have. Again, fell back to reading the bullet points on the screen and handed it off.

I’m sure it was painful to watch.

It was the worst night of my college career. I allowed my emotions to cloud my thinking and affect my performance. I felt horrible, mainly because I wanted to do a decent job for the other teammate who actually carried most of the workload. I hoped that the instructor would not hold my poor performance against him. Aside from being incredibly embarrassed, I was disappointed in myself. Although I don’t consider myself to be the most eloquent speaker, I do technical training at work. I should have been able to recover and continue. Instead, I stood there fumbling like an idiot. My only reprieve was that the torture would soon be over.

And now, on to the lessons I learned. There has to be something positive gained from such an awful experience, right?

  • Not everyone will be as motivated as I expect them to be. Some people will not take the initiative to do anything. For those people, perhaps a little more hand-holding is required. Perhaps they needed more direction. Not everyone is a self-starter.
  • When I get flustered just prior to a presentation, take a moment to step outside, take a deep breath and clear my mind. It could mean the difference between a good presentation — and one that makes me want to bludgeon myself with a blunt object.
  • Something I learned about myself today: I am no good if I am emotional. Sometimes a disconnect is needed. I shouldn’t take things so seriously and/or personally.
  • Embarrassment is temporary. Even the most dreadful of experiences, though they seem like eternities, are quickly forgotten. I’m sure no one in my class will remember my bumbling presentation a week from now.

Now that I got my nervous breakdown out of the way, maybe I can survive my last 4 scheduled classes unscathed. However, if I have teammates like that again, I may need to acquire a taste of alcohol. It would definitely drive me to drink.

All I can say is, thank God this class is over.

6 Responses to “Pain and Humiliation”

  1. Andreason 13 Oct 2005 at 2:13 am

    Allow me to say something to your great entry.

    The great part of your post is that you take the learning along. Remember, there is no failure only feedback, and you understand this.

    Next - most of the time, “people” are worried that their nervousness comes thru on stage, but please be assured that mostly, it doesnt. Probably nobody recognised how you performed, and what you thought was bad, was just a game in your mind. And if - it doesn’t matter, since you have your learning.

    What I think went wrong was that you build yourself up emotionally negatively in the beginning, before the presentation. That badly influenced your state of mind, and that is probably the reason that something went wrong, if something actually went wrong (see my second point).

    Another learning: Dont let this experience influence your future presentation skill. Next time is another chance okay!!

  2. Yukoon 13 Oct 2005 at 2:52 am

    Otsukaresama-, Donna! A couple of things came to mind when I read your post-all from the point of view knowing that I don’t know you very well (yet, I hope!): 1)I suspect you may be extremely hard on yourself and that maybe the presentation wasn’t as bad as it felt. But then again, if I trust that your account was not exaggerated, then you are ‘right on’ to focus on points #2, #3, and #4; 2) despite the stress of your non-contributing team members, I’m in awe of your compassion (point #1)–it would be interesting to see whether a different approach would’ve helped that person(s) become more motivated or whether it still might not have made a difference–at least for this time round. I suspect this person has probably set a pattern where people around him do end up “rescuing”–if only to save themselves! Perhaps a different approach might at least alter his consciousness of being a team member.

    Congrats on finishing the class and good luck with the rest! I’m inspired that you’re in school! I plan on going back when I’m stateside and I’m learning and remembering from your experience! Chibariyo-

  3. Matsuon 13 Oct 2005 at 6:45 am

    geez wtf? cowards off with thier heads! where’s Ray when you need him? lol

    I stand in awe of ur l33tness in handliing the situation without resorting without resorting to behavior that would lead to the next mass extinction.

    Twinkies and Red Bull for everyone

    w00t!

  4. Ayakoon 13 Oct 2005 at 7:39 am

    Hi Donna,

    Wow. My sympathies. I personally experienced your lesson #1 at work a few years ago. It was disappointing to say the least, for all of involved, I’m sure.

    Anyway, you’ve realized my worst fears about grad school - group work! So far the group I’m in is awesome and everyone puts in a lot of effort. I lucked out, I think.

    Thanks for summarizing your experience in your lessons learned, they’re valuable to me as I start grad school and it sounds like it’s been valuable to you as well, despite the pain.

    Congrats on completing the class nevertheless! Just a couple more to go, right? Gambatte!

  5. aprilon 13 Oct 2005 at 10:59 am

    I am absolutely certain that after several weeks of sharing a class with many people, they all saw your ambition and dedication. I am equally certain that they saw that you were the one carrying your “Team” and probably respected you all the more for your heavy load! Believe me, lack of commitment shows and those guys who were woefully unprepared and left you to pick up the slack probably came across as fools.

    Congrats on another class behind you!

  6. champuru.net » 5 and countingon 04 May 2006 at 9:55 pm

    [...] Well, as a result of being determinedly unmotivated to take my CLEPs, I enrolled myself back in school to finish off the last of my required courses. Evidently, I’ve forgotten all about the pain and suffering that one often has to endure in school, when I could have easily avoided the classroom simply by hunkering down and taking those darned exams. [...]

Trackback URI |